Close this search box.
"Bartender mixing an Old Overholt cocktail with ingredients and bar tools in view."

Old Overholt Cocktail: A Must-Try Recipe for Whiskey Lovers

Are you a cocktail enthusiast eager to elevate your home bartending skills? Look no further! The old overholt cocktail is a must-try for any whiskey lover. This timeless drink combines rich flavors and a touch of sophistication, making it perfect for any occasion. Ready to mix up a classic? Let’s dive in.

In this recipe:

  • 2 oz Old Overholt Rye Whiskey
  • 1 oz Sweet Vermouth
  • 2 dashes Angostura Bitters
  • Orange peel (optional, for garnish)
  • Chill, stir, garnish, and enjoy!

If you’re a fan of classic cocktails, you might also enjoy our Espresso Martini recipe. Or, for something a bit more exotic, check out the Nobu Lychee Martini. Both are sure to impress your guests and elevate your cocktail game.

Ingredients for making an old overholt cocktail, including rye whiskey, bitters, and garnish.

Who Can Make This Recipe and What You Need

This Old Overholt Cocktail recipe is suitable for everyone, whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned home bartender. It’s classified as an easy to moderate difficulty level, making it accessible to all skill levels. So, if you’re eager to master some bartending techniques, this drink is a perfect start.

Essential Equipment

To make this cocktail, you’ll need some basic kitchen equipment:

  • Mixing glass
  • Strainer
  • Cocktail glass

You don’t need any fancy cocktail shaker types for this recipe, just the essentials. If you’re curious about how to stock a home bar, starting with these basic tools is a great first step.

New to cocktail-making? Avoid common cocktail-making mistakes like over-stirring or using the wrong glassware. With a bit of practice, you’ll perfect this classic cocktail in no time.

For more detailed guidance, check out this Old Overholt Cocktail recipe from Home and Texture. They offer great tips to ensure your cocktail turns out just right.

The Ingredients Needed

Now that we’ve covered the minimal equipment needed to make this delightful cocktail, let’s dive into the specifics of the ingredients. Choosing the right ingredients is crucial for achieving the perfect balance and flavor in your Old Overholt Cocktail. Each component plays a vital role in creating a harmonious blend, making every sip an enjoyable experience.

Essential Ingredients for the Perfect Old Overholt Cocktail

Here’s what you’ll need:

  • 2 oz Old Overholt Rye Whiskey: This is the heart of your cocktail. Old Overholt is known for its bold, spicy flavor, which forms the base of many classic whiskey-based cocktails.
  • 1 oz Sweet Vermouth: This ingredient adds a touch of sweetness and depth to your drink. It’s a crucial component in many traditional recipes, including the Manhattan.
  • 2 dashes Angostura Bitters: These bitters add complexity and a hint of spice, balancing the sweetness of the vermouth.

Gathering these ingredients is straightforward, and they are commonly found in most liquor stores. When selecting your sweet vermouth, opt for high-quality brands like Carpano Antica or Cinzano to elevate your cocktail. The choice of vermouth can greatly influence the final taste, so it’s worth investing in a good one.

With these simple ingredients, you’re well on your way to creating a classic Old Overholt Cocktail. Have you tried making whiskey-based cocktails before? If not, this is the perfect recipe to start with. It’s simple yet sophisticated, making it a favorite among both novice and seasoned cocktail enthusiasts.

Step-by-Step Guide on How to Make an Old Overholt Cocktail

Now that we’ve gathered all the ingredients, let’s dive into the process. Follow these simple steps, and soon you’ll be enjoying a classic Old Overholt Cocktail.

Mixing the Ingredients

First, fill a mixing glass with ice. This will help chill the cocktail as you mix. Next, pour in the Old Overholt Rye Whiskey, Sweet Vermouth, and Angostura Bitters over the ice. These ingredients are the heart of your cocktail, and getting the proportions right is key.

Now, stir the mixture for approximately 30 seconds. This step is crucial for chilling and diluting the ingredients to perfection. Use a bar spoon for the best results. If you’re wondering how to stir cocktails properly, remember to stir gently. The goal is to mix without over-aerating the drink.

After stirring, strain the cocktail into a chilled coupe or cocktail glass. This ensures your drink stays cold and free of ice shards. For garnishing, consider using an orange peel. It’s not only a classic touch but also adds a hint of citrus aroma. If you’re looking for more cocktail garnishing tips, try experimenting with a citrus twist to elevate the flavor profile.

And there you have it! You’ve learned how to make an Old Overholt Cocktail, mastering a timeless recipe. Whether you’re curious about how to make an Old Fashioned or how to make a Manhattan, the techniques you’ve practiced here will serve you well.

If you have any leftover cocktail, store it in an airtight container in the fridge. It will stay fresh for up to 24 hours, so you can enjoy it later. Cheers to your mixing skills and happy sipping!

Serving and Storing Ideas and Tips

Now that you’ve mastered the steps on how to make an Old Overholt Cocktail, let’s dive into some practical tips for serving and storing this classic drink. Whether you’re a seasoned mixologist or a home-bartending newbie, these simple tips will ensure your cocktail is always served at its best.

When it comes to how to serve whiskey, the presentation is key. Start by serving the Old Overholt Cocktail in a chilled glass to enhance its refreshing quality. If you want to elevate your cocktail experience, consider using clear ice for cocktails. Clear ice not only looks stunning but also melts slower, keeping your drink cool without diluting the flavors too quickly.

Pairing Your Cocktail with Food

Pairing your Old Overholt Cocktail with the right food can elevate your drinking experience. The complex flavors of rye whiskey pair exceptionally well with a variety of dishes. Think about serving it alongside rich, savory appetizers like charcuterie boards or spicy snacks to complement its bold taste. For a more substantial pairing, consider grilled meats or barbecue, which can stand up to the strong, spicy notes of the rye.

After you’ve enjoyed your cocktail, you might wonder how to store any leftovers. While it’s always best to consume your cocktail fresh, you can store any remaining mix in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours. This helps preserve the flavors, ensuring your next sip is just as delightful.

For those who love to experiment, try using large ice cubes for cocktails. They melt slower than smaller ones, keeping your drink chilled without watering it down. Plus, they add a touch of sophistication to your presentation.

Remember, the key to a great cocktail is not just in the ingredients but also in how you serve and store it. With these tips, you’ll always have a perfectly chilled Old Overholt Cocktail ready to impress your guests or enjoy on your own.

Pro Tips for the Perfect Old Overholt Cocktail

  • Always use fresh ice to ensure proper chilling.
  • For a smoother cocktail, stir gently for 30 seconds.
  • Experiment with different sweet vermouth brands.
  • Use a chilled glass for the best experience.
  • Consider using homemade bitters for a unique twist.
  • Store Old Overholt Rye Whiskey in a cool, dark place.
  • Adjust the Angostura Bitters to match your taste preference.
  • Try a citrus twist instead of an orange peel for garnish.


Welcome to the FAQ section! Here, we’ll answer some common questions about making the Old Overholt Cocktail and other whiskey cocktails. Let’s dive in!

Questions About Making the Old Overholt Cocktail

Q: Can I substitute other types of whiskey for Old Overholt Rye Whiskey?

A: Yes, you can substitute other types of whiskey, but the flavor profile will change. For example, using bourbon will result in a sweeter taste, while another rye whiskey might have a spicier kick. Experiment to find your preference, but remember that Old Overholt Rye Whiskey has a unique character that shines in this cocktail.

Q: What are some money-saving tips for choosing sweet vermouth?

A: You don’t need to break the bank for a good sweet vermouth. Affordable yet quality options include brands like Dolin and Cinzano. These vermouths offer great flavor and won’t overshadow the whiskey. Check out this link for more tips on choosing vermouth.

Q: How can I adjust the amount of Angostura Bitters?

A: The amount of Angostura Bitters can be modified to suit your taste. Start with two dashes as the recipe suggests. If you prefer a stronger bitters flavor, add an extra dash. Conversely, if you want a milder taste, reduce to one dash. It’s all about finding the right balance for your palate.

Questions About Making Other Whiskey Cocktails

Q: What is the best rye whiskey for a Manhattan?

A: While Old Overholt is an excellent choice for its affordability and quality, other top contenders include Rittenhouse Rye and Bulleit Rye. These options offer robust flavors that complement the sweet vermouth and bitters in a Manhattan, making them popular choices among bartenders.

Q: Are there any easy whiskey cocktails I can try?

A: Absolutely! Some easy whiskey cocktails include the Whiskey Sour, Old Fashioned, and Boulevardier. These classics are simple to make and require minimal ingredients, perfect for both beginners and seasoned enthusiasts. You can find more recipes and tips on sites like Home Bar Menu.

We hope these answers help you craft the perfect whiskey cocktails with confidence. Happy mixing!


Hello There!

I’m Ben, the culinary enthusiast and voice behind Simple Recipe Box. Welcome to my little corner of the internet, a place where I share my passion for simple, yet delicious meals that cater to cooks of all levels.

More Recipes